Understanding the High CEO Pay: Insights from Starbucks

The AFL‑CIO Executive Paywatch report, leveraging recent 2024 SEC filings, highlights that Starbucks CEO Brian Niccol's compensation reached nearly $98 million, marking him as the highest-paid CEO among the 500 largest U.S. public companies. This represents a jaw-dropping 6,666 times more than the typical worker at Starbucks, who earns less than $15,000 annually.

While it's true Niccol's compensation is an outlier, it mirrors a wider trend observed across S&P 500 companies, where the average CEO's pay hit $18.9 million in 2024, equating to 285 times the median worker's salary of $49,500. This is an increase from a ratio of 268:1 in 2023. Industry leaders like Bob Iger at Disney and CEOs from firms like Axon, Netflix, Apple, and JPMorgan also earn substantial packages.

Decoding CEO Compensation

1. Performance-Based Pay Structures

Executive compensation often revolves around measurable metrics such as stock performance, total shareholder return, and earnings per share growth. CEOs like Niccol are granted significant long-term equity to align their outcomes with shareholder interests, though critics argue these incentives can sometimes reward less-than-stellar results, not proportional to median employee contributions.

Image 2

2. The Talent Acquisition Arms Race

Multinational corporations contend that securing elite leadership in global markets necessitates high-level compensation. Retaining executives able to guide expansive consumer and tech firms forces boards to offer large rewards, in part due to benchmarking within top-tier compensation circles.

3. Corporate Governance Dynamics

Often, compensation committees are not independent of management. Research shows compensation consultants contribute to inflation in CEO pay by focusing on top percentile benchmarks. In some cases, CEOs can influence boards, reducing checks and reinforcing high-compensation practices.

A component of the stark ratio in Niccol’s scenario stems from Starbucks’ workforce, mostly comprising part-time employees, many of whom are students or have barista roles as secondary jobs. Additionally, Starbucks extends a range of benefits even to part-timers.

Image 3

Corporate Responsibility and CEO Compensation

While large executive pay packages invite scrutiny, proponents argue that such compensation reflects the intense responsibilities shouldered by CEOs, influencing shareholder returns, brand stability, and employee success. At Starbucks, for instance, Brian Niccol’s strategic appointment draws from a successful tenure at Chipotle where he led brand revival efforts post-food safety crises, rebuilding trust and profitability, a compelling reason for his hiring at Starbucks.

Advocates for performance-driven remuneration argue that successful leadership can produce a “ripple effect”—leading to higher stock prices, job security, strengthened retirement plans, and investment in employee skills and infrastructure. Niccol’s "Back to Starbucks" initiative is a notable example, involving $500 million in labor and store hours investments, along with planned enhancements to 1,000 stores by 2026, including service upgrades and menu innovations.

It’s essential to recognize that many major corporations with extensive CEO-to-worker pay gaps still prioritize employee development and social impact initiatives. At Apple, CEO Tim Cook—earning 1447:1 more than employees—has managed substantial advances in workforce education and sustainability, while JPMorgan Chase’s Jamie Dimon advocates workforce reentry and small business lending in underserved areas. Walmart, frequently critiqued over CEO pay, has raised its average hourly wage to over $17 and launched tuition-free college programs for employees. Such initiatives underscore how executive leadership can positively impact workers, particularly when companies are transparent about investing in human capital and community engagement.

The ultimate measure of success—financial performance, employee benefits, and sustainable growth—becomes apparent over time. Amid compensation debates, there remains a perspective where executive pay is seen as one part of broader corporate responsibility and value creation. For those navigating the tax implications of executive compensation, understanding its impact on corporate strategy and investment is crucial. Feel free to reach out to our office for expert guidance on tax planning and resolution.

Share this article...

Sign up for our newsletter.

Each month, we will send you a roundup of our latest blog content covering the tax and accounting tips & insights you need to know.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .

We care about the protection of your data.