Italy's Expanding Tax Gap: A Challenge for Economic Stability

Italy is grappling with a tax evasion crisis of unexpected proportions, highlighting the challenges of maintaining fiscal compliance across Europe. The latest figures, reviewed by Reuters, reveal a surge in unpaid taxes and social contributions to €102.5 billion ($119 billion) in 2022, a rise from €99 billion the previous year.

This reversal disrupts what was previously seen as a gradual improvement in tax compliance, with the problem re-emerging since 2020. For Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, these findings present a contentious issue. Her government has challenged the effectiveness of stringent enforcement methods, preferring to relax rules — notably raising the cash payment limit and introducing tax amnesties for debts from 2023.

Critics argue that such leniency effectively endorses tax evasion. Economists caution that these measures might unravel a decade’s worth of progress toward financial transparency. Deputy Economy Minister Maurizio Leo starkly referred to tax evasion as akin to "terrorism" during a parliamentary debate, underscoring the need for enhanced monitoring of undisclosed incomes.

Understanding the Revised Metrics

The national statistics agency, ISTAT, updated its data collection methods in 2024. Their findings exposed a much deeper level of non-compliance than previously recorded. Between 2018 and 2022, real progress in tackling evasion was only €5.9 billion, contrary to the previously claimed €26 billion improvement.

These statistics hold weight not only for domestic politics but also for negotiations with the EU. With Rome under pressure from Brussels to lower its debt-to-GDP ratio of about 137%, the fiscal gap poses significant challenges. More evasion means less revenue, complicating these efforts.

Italy in the European Scene

Italy's "shadow economy" remains prominent in Europe. Eurostat highlights a preference for cash among Italians compared to other major eurozone countries, despite incentives for digital payment adoption. Other nations like Spain, France, and Germany have successfully reduced their unreported economies post-pandemic, but Italy’s remains notably high.

Meloni’s strategy to relax penalties with the hope that it will promote voluntary tax compliance appears risky—findings from the University of Bologna suggest such programs only yield 35–40% of the owed taxes.

What Lies Ahead

In response, the 2026 budget proposes another widespread tax amnesty, allowing settlements without penalties or interest—a decision the European Commission has already criticized as "fiscally risky." Beyond political strategy, Italy’s issue with tax evasion is entrenched in cultural and structural norms, evolving over decades.

Italy’s escalating €100 billion tax gap signals more than financial strain—it jeopardizes the country’s fiscal stability, investor confidence, and its reputation within the EU. Without innovative solutions, Italy’s underground economy threatens not only its own fiscal outlook but potentially its influence over Europe’s economic landscape.

Share this article...

Facebook

Twitter WhatsApp LinkedIn Pinterest Pocket Reddit Email

Sign up for our newsletter.

Each month, we will send you a roundup of our latest blog content covering the tax and accounting tips & insights you need to know.

I confirm this is a service inquiry and not an advertising message or solicitation. By clicking “Submit”, I acknowledge and agree to the creation of an account and to the and .

We care about the protection of your data.